The goth rockers, fronted by the charismatic and only remaining original member Andrew Eldritch, are among the bands I’ve seen live the most times; with Monday's concert, I'm approaching double digits.
Eldritch is also, together with Bob Dylan (whom I’ve probably seen 15 times), one of the two artists about whom I’ve thought after every concert for the past two decades, "This wasn’t any good. You can hardly see him, and can he even sing properly anymore? That’s enough, never again."
But still, I’m there almost every time they show up in Sweden. Some kind of masochism might be involved in this.
But there’s definitely a strong dose of nostalgia at play. I started listening to both Sisters and Dylan at the age of 18, and I’m in some ways forever shaped by the music. When I first saw Sisters in Berlin in the early 90s, it was one of the most powerful experiences I’d ever had.
So when Eldritch & co step onto the stage in the obligatory cloud of smoke, I feel a familiar excitement in my body at the thought of hearing the classic songs from the three albums released between 1985–1991.
But I should have known better. More than half the songs played that evening came much later and still haven’t been released commercially, not even as demos or live versions. Eldritch seems to harbor an unforgiving hatred toward the music industry in general and record labels in particular, so a new album is hardly happening.
Which is a shame, as some of the songs are quite okay. For example, both Crash and burn and Arms work reasonably well this evening, cast in the Vision Thing mold from 1991. But the rest of the "new" songs are anonymous and sound
similar, with thin and monotonous beats from the drum machine Doktor Avalanche, and competent hard rock riffing from the two guitarists.
And what about the old favorites, you might wonder. Well, not that fun either. Sure, I get chills when the intro to Alice makes its entrance, as well as with the synth lines in Giving Ground from the side project Sisterhood. But the other songs just blend together into a monotonous metal racket. You only realize they're playing Ribbons, Dr Jeep, and Marian when the chorus comes in.
Additionally, Eldritch’s voice loses both depth and power with each passing minute. His once mighty baritone lasts only through the first five or six songs, then it’s mostly growling and mumbling behind the nearly parodic amounts of smoke.
Eldritch himself doesn’t seem to care much about that. He paces back and forth on stage, or stops to kneel and crouch, while, like Thåström, he waves and twists his fingers. More than once, I think that Eldritch’s spider-like figure reminds me of Gollum, and the illusion of a cool rock star fades more and more as the concert goes on.
The band finishes with the obvious hits Lucretia My Reflection and This Corrosion, and it’s after all quite a maxed-out finale. At the same time, I’m reminded of a comment in an old Reddit thread, where someone wrote that seeing Sisters today is like finding your childhood stuffed animal after it’s been in a box in the attic for 20 years.
It brings back fond memories, but it’s also old, dusty, and smells a little weird, and you’re afraid it might crumble in your hands. Some things are probably best left as just memories. Maybe I’ve finally learned that this time.